The New York Times: Should young women sell their eggs?

The New York Times wrote about egg donation and included The Cost of Life in this Oct. 21, 2016, piece.

“Justine Griffin submitted an application to donate her eggs to a fertility clinic in Florida, detailing everything about herself from her appearance to her SAT scores. An infertile couple liked what they saw on paper and Ms. Griffin was notified that they wanted to buy her eggs.”

How much should egg donors be compensated? Let them decide.

I wrote an op-ed piece about egg donor compensation following a front page story in the New York Times about egg donation, which brought about a national discussion on the topic.

eggs

My ovaries were the size of grapefruits, the eggs inside them ultra-ripened by the fertility drugs I had injected. I was too bloated and sore to fit into a pair of jeans. I was an emotional train wreck.

But when I was admitted to the Women’s Center ward of Tampa General Hospital, it was not because there was something wrong with me. It was because there was something inside of me someone else wanted. My eggs.

And I couldn’t wait for the doctor to literally pluck them out of me.

After a 20-minute surgery, five of my eggs had been removed and were on their way to being fertilized. Nine months later, twin boys who looked at least half like me were born in the same hospital, but I’d never know them. They now live in Ireland.

I got what was promised to me: a check for $5,000, a price I should have every right to negotiate.

Women can receive up to $10,000 for their eggs in the United States, a cap that donors are challenging in federal court this year as outlined by a class action lawsuit. In the suit they accuse the two professional medical organizations that set guidelines for in vitro fertilization practices and the fertility clinics associated with them of illegal price-fixing.

The case could go to trial next year.

In my instance, of course I wanted to help a couple start a family, but what lured me to consider donating my eggs was the money. A couple grand could pay for a semester of college. It could be a down payment on a house. Or fund a trip overseas. It helped me pay off credit card bills. The money went too fast.

Last December, about a year after my egg donation, I returned to Tampa General Hospital to visit my cousin, who is just a year older than me and was having complications with her pregnancy. She had miscarried before, so the health of this baby boy was so important.

I stopped by the familiar hospital on my way home from speaking to a journalism class at the University of Tampa. I was tired, cramping and uncomfortable. But when I walked into the hospital room just a few doors down from where I had been admitted, I felt foolish.

My cousin Danielle was in real pain. Though she was stable, there was a serious risk to her child. Her pregnant sister sat next to her in a chair. My aunt stood over her two big-bellied girls.

Sure, I was sore and bloated. My menstrual cycle was irregular and painful. I was still dealing with the aftereffects of having been an egg donor. I couldn’t find a birth control method that was both comfortable and effective in this new and temperamental post-donation body of mine. But my lingering pain was nothing compared to what they were going through.

Wasn’t this why I had decided to donate my eggs in the first place? To help a woman who struggled to conceive on her own?

After my donation, the agency that recruited me offered me $7,500 to donate again, this time to a gay couple in France. When I declined, the price went up. I’m 27 now, and I’ve met egg donors who have donated more than six times, and were paid anywhere from $3,000 to $10,000 for their eggs. They donated at clinics in Florida and some were flown to California for two weeks and a surgery.

There have been cases where the graduate of an elite university like Stanford or Harvard has made $50,000 or more for donating eggs. Some egg donors negotiate in contracts to keep and freeze some of the eggs collected for themselves. Sometimes unused but fertilized eggs are donated to another couple or an embryo donation clinic without the consent of the original egg donor. There are no absolute rules here, but the majority of fertility clinics stick to the guidelines and cap compensation at $10,000 per donation.

This federal lawsuit, and recent articles in the New York Times, shed light on the evolving, mostly unregulated world of the $3 billion fertility industry, where technology now exists to test embryos for genetic diseases and prospective parents can literally select the attributes they want in their child through egg and sperm donors. I know I was picked for my long legs and blonde hair.

This isn’t a question of whether or not egg donation should be legal. It’s here and it’s not going away. The science has helped cancer survivors, infertile women and same-sex couples participate in child-rearing from the start — from in the womb — in ways that would otherwise not be possible for them.

It’s not all that uncommon to hear stories about IVF cycles and children born of donor sex cells as more parents postpone childbirth until later in life. Donated eggs were used in 20,000 monthly IVF cycles in 2012, compared to fewer than 12,000 used a decade earlier, according to data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

With 7.3 million people experiencing fertility trouble in the United States, it’s no wonder egg donation has become an $80 million market.

So why shouldn’t the women who donate their time, and assume the health risks associated with hormone injections and a minor surgery, dictate the price they should be paid? Despite the opportunity to make more money, I chose not to donate again. I wound up in the ER shortly after my donation cycle because of a ruptured cyst, a minor aftereffect, but a painful and scary one nonetheless. That’s nothing compared to ovarian hyperstimulation syndome, a painful swelling of the ovaries, which in rare cases can lead to hospitalization or death.

But I do believe donors should have the right to negotiate our own compensation. And knowing what I know now, if I were to “donate” again, I would charge more — a lot more.

The laws surrounding exchanges like this vary from state to state, though it’s illegal to sell any bodily tissue for money in the United States. Fertility clinics skirt such rules by calling it a donation. As a donor, the $5,000 I received was compensation for my time and discomfort.

The process is much more involved than donating sperm and, thus, the compensation should be. This discussion seems eerily reminiscent of the more mainstream conversations about abortion. If a woman has decided to donate her eggs in exchange for money, whether it be to another woman, to an egg bank or even for research, then she is exercising her right to do so. No one else should step in to make that decision for her or declare its worth.

Science is lengthening our lives and eliminating diseases. In this case, it’s also creating a booming babymaking industry. Doctors stand to make thousands from couples who choose this route for family planning. It’s given birth to new businesses — agencies that specialize in pairing egg donors and surrogate mothers with prospective parents.

It prompts the question: What’s next?

If women are allowed to openly sell their eggs, are we potentially creating a market to sell other organs, too? What’s the difference between legally selling a kidney and selling an egg, if the individuals are willing to do so and will be compensated?

I don’t think I would donate a kidney for money, even though I donated my eggs for cash. But if my cousin needed a kidney, I wouldn’t hesitate.

Danielle eventually gave birth to a beautiful and healthy baby boy. Her sister delivered a healthy baby girl shortly after. When I look at these youngsters at family gatherings, I’m reminded of the two boys out there in the world that came from my egg donation. The money may be gone already, but they’re alive and well with parents who wanted them so much, they were willing to spend thousands of dollars to bring them into this world. And I’m okay with that.

Justine Griffin is a business reporter with the Tampa Bay Times. She wrote a long-form piece about her experience as an egg donor for the Sarasota Herald-Tribune last year. Read more about her egg donation at costoflife.heraldtribune.com.

Knight Science Journalism Review

Knight Science Journalism at MIT operates the KSJ Tracker, which featured a blurb about  The Cost of Life on June 24, 2014.

The review was written by Paul Raeborn, a media critic.

The Cost of Life is well worth your time. If it had run in the New York Times, it would be news across the country now, and we would be seeing Griffin interviewed by Charlie Rose. In the media capital here in New York City, where we’re accustomed to thinking that we know everything, it’s important to be reminded that good journalism can be done anywhere.”

Read the full review here.

 

The Cost of Life: Excerpts for additional publications

The Cost of Life ran excerpts in the following publications:

COST OF LIFE_04

 

The Cost of Life: My experience as a first-time egg donor ran an as an excerpt on the Huffington Post Women page on June 5, 2014.

***

An original excerpt published in The Riverter Magazine on April 18, 2014.

Editor and founder of The Riveter, Kaylen Ralph, published a Q&A with Justine Griffin the week prior to the excerpt.

 ***

We Are Egg Donors, an egg donor activist and resources group, published a Q&A with Justine Griffin on May 21, 2014.

***

The Gainesville Sun and the Ocala Star-Banner, both Halifax Media Group-owned newspapers, published 900-word excerpts of The Cost of Life on Sunday, May 25.

***

longreadsLongreads featured The Cost of Life on its website in June.

Slate.com’s Double X Podcast mentioned The Cost of Life and linked to the story in a July 10 episode.

The Washington Post pulled quotes and reporting from The Cost of Life in a July 21 Storyline piece.

Medium featured The Cost of Life in this June 5 piece about the fertility industry and again in this Jan. 17 piece about the pursuit of pregnancy.

Wired Magazine mentioned The Cost of Life in this Oct. 24 piece about egg freezing.

Paste Magazine included The Cost of Life on a list of the best short read pieces in January.

The Crow’s Nest (USF student publication) wrote about The Cost of Life on Nov. 15, 2015.

COST OF LIFE_05

Photo by Elaine Litherland

 

The Cost of Life: On-air appearances

Kelly Mcbride from the Poynter Institute of Media Studies interviewed Justine Griffin about her project, The Cost of Life. The interview focused on the ethical issues that surrounded the project. As her approach morphed from a personal essay to an investigative package, Griffin had to deal with her own conflict of interest. She was part of the story.


Huff Post Live interviewed Justine Griffin about The cost of Life on Friday, June 5, 2014, as apart of the “What’s Trending” segment.

On June 10, Huff Post Live held a follow up discussion with Raquel Cool, from We Are Egg Donors, to discuss regulatory issues in egg donation.

The Sarasota News Network interviewed Justine Griffin about The Cost of Life on Friday, May 23, prior to the story publishing that Sunday.

***

Justine Griffin was interviewed by Steve Newborn of WUSF, the Tampa NPR radio affiliate, on June 5, 2014.

Maternally YoursJustine Griffin was featured on Maternally Yours, a radio show about fertility, during a segment on egg donation.